Atlanta Falcons’ Bold Quarterback Moves: Kirk Cousins Benched for Michael Penix
When the Atlanta Falcons signed Kirk Cousins to a four-year, $180 million deal last offseason, the consensus was that the team was going all-in to try and win a Super Bowl. However, they pulled off a shock move in the 2024 NFL Draft, selecting quarterback Michael Penix with the eighth overall pick. This unexpected decision suggested that the Falcons weren’t entirely confident in Cousins’ long-term viability as their franchise quarterback.
A Sudden Shift in Plans
The Falcons’ concerns about Cousins’ effectiveness came true sooner than expected. Just fourteen games into the season, the team made the dramatic decision to bench the veteran quarterback in favor of the rookie. With Penix now positioned as the team’s starting quarterback moving forward, Atlanta is actively looking for ways to part ways with Cousins.
However, this transition comes with significant complications. Cousins’ contract includes a no-trade clause, meaning he holds full control over any potential move. He has reportedly made it clear that he will only waive this clause for a team he believes has a legitimate shot at winning the Super Bowl.
The Challenge of Moving Cousins
The problem for Atlanta is that no contending team is currently in desperate need of a new starting quarterback. Most playoff-caliber teams have their quarterback situations settled, leaving the Falcons in an awkward position. As a result, they are now facing the reality of carrying the most expensive backup quarterback in NFL history heading into the 2025 season.
Falcons’ Potential Plan to Move On
NFL insider Tom Pelissero believes the Falcons may have a trick up their sleeve to persuade Cousins to leave this offseason. While details of their strategy remain unclear, it is possible that they could restructure his contract, explore potential buyout options, or apply strategic pressure to make his position with the team untenable.
Possible Outcomes
- Trade to a Rebuilding Team – While Cousins prefers a contender, he may eventually reconsider his stance if an attractive situation arises where he could serve as a bridge quarterback.
- Restructure and Release – The Falcons could negotiate an adjusted contract that allows them to move on while still compensating Cousins fairly.
- Holding the Most Expensive Backup – If no deal is reached, Atlanta may be forced to keep Cousins on the roster as an extremely costly insurance policy behind Penix.
- Unexpected Injury Opens a Door – Quarterback injuries are common in the NFL. A contending team losing its starter could suddenly create a trade market for Cousins.
Looking Ahead
For now, the Falcons appear committed to Michael Penix as their future. The decision to draft him early and move on from Cousins so quickly underscores their belief in the rookie’s potential. As the 2025 season approaches, all eyes will be on Atlanta to see how they navigate this tricky quarterback dilemma.
Regardless of what happens, this situation will be one of the biggest storylines in the NFL, with potential ramifications for both the Falcons and the league at large.
