Colin Cowherd’s Bold Take: Is Shedeur Sanders the Next Brock Purdy

Colin Cowherd, host of The Herd with Colin Cowherd, has always been known for his bold takes on sports. His latest commentary on Colorado quarterback Shedeur Sanders is no exception. Cowherd recently stated that NFL general managers may be underestimating Sanders, drawing a comparison between him and San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy.

During the show, Cowherd emphasized that Sanders has been producing impressive numbers despite playing behind one of the worst offensive lines in college football and without a strong running game. He argued that, much like Purdy, Sanders possesses elite processing ability, accuracy, and mobility—qualities that make for a successful NFL quarterback.

This claim has sparked considerable debate among fans and analysts. While some agree with Cowherd’s assessment, others believe that Sanders’ skill set is not on the same level as Purdy’s. In this article, we will examine the similarities and differences between Sanders and Purdy, analyze how Sanders’ college experience could translate to the NFL, and evaluate whether Cowherd’s take holds merit.

Shedeur Sanders’ College Performance: Overcoming Adversity

Shedeur Sanders has been a standout quarterback for the Colorado Buffaloes, and before that, at Jackson State under his father, NFL Hall of Famer Deion Sanders. His collegiate journey has been marked by both impressive statistics and significant challenges.

Statistical Excellence

Despite playing in less-than-ideal circumstances, Sanders has consistently delivered strong performances. In the 2023 season with Colorado, he posted impressive passing numbers:

• 3,230 passing yards
• 27 touchdowns
• Only 3 interceptions
• Completion rate of 69.3%

These numbers illustrate his accuracy, decision-making, and ability to protect the football. While his offensive line struggled—allowing him to be sacked a staggering 52 times—Sanders still managed to keep his composure and make plays.

Lack of Support in the Running Game

One of the biggest factors working against Sanders has been Colorado’s inefficient rushing attack. The Buffaloes ranked among the worst Power Five teams in rushing offense, which put additional pressure on Sanders to carry the offense. Despite this, he remained productive and showcased his ability to read defenses and make quick decisions under duress.

Brock Purdy’s Rise in the NFL: A Blueprint for Sanders?

Brock Purdy’s NFL journey is one of the most remarkable stories in recent memory. Drafted as Mr. Irrelevant in the seventh round of the 2022 NFL Draft, Purdy exceeded all expectations and led the San Francisco 49ers to the NFC Championship Game in his rookie season.

Similar Traits to Sanders

Cowherd’s comparison between Sanders and Purdy is based on key shared attributes:

1. Elite Processing Ability – Both quarterbacks excel at making quick decisions and reading defenses.
2. Accuracy – Purdy boasts a career completion rate of 67.8% in the NFL, and Sanders has displayed similar precision at the collegiate level.
3. Athleticism – Neither quarterback is known for elite speed, but both can extend plays and maneuver within the pocket when needed.
4. Poise Under Pressure – Purdy has demonstrated his ability to remain calm and execute under pressure, a trait Sanders has also displayed despite constant pressure in Colorado’s offense.

Differences Between Purdy and Sanders

While there are similarities, some key differences must be acknowledged:

1. Supporting Cast – Purdy stepped into an NFL system with elite weapons (Deebo Samuel, Christian McCaffrey, George Kittle) and one of the league’s best play-callers, Kyle Shanahan. Sanders may not have the same luxury early in his NFL career.
2. Competition Level – Purdy played at Iowa State, a Power Five school, for four years, while Sanders started at Jackson State before transferring to Colorado. Some critics argue that Sanders’ competition level before moving to Colorado was not as rigorous as Purdy’s.
3. Draft Projection – Unlike Purdy, who was a late-round pick, Sanders is widely projected as a potential first-round or second-round selection. The expectations surrounding him will be much higher.

How Shedeur Sanders Projects as an NFL Quarterback

Strengths

• High Football IQ: Sanders’ ability to read defenses and make quick decisions is one of his strongest assets.
• Ball Security: With only three interceptions last season, he shows excellent decision-making under pressure.
• Pocket Awareness: Despite facing heavy pressure, Sanders displays composure in the pocket and the ability to maneuver effectively.
• Accuracy: His 69.3% completion rate demonstrates his ability to deliver precise throws consistently.

Areas for Improvement

• Arm Strength: While not a weakness, Sanders does not possess an elite arm like some of the top NFL prospects (e.g., Caleb Williams, Drake Maye).
• Handling Pressure: While he remains composed, Sanders has been sacked frequently. Learning to get the ball out quicker in the NFL will be crucial.
• Deep Ball Consistency: While accurate in short and intermediate throws, he needs to improve his downfield passing ability.

NFL Teams That Could Be a Fit for Sanders

If Sanders declares for the NFL Draft, several teams may be interested in his skill set. Here are some potential fits:

1. Las Vegas Raiders – The Raiders need a young quarterback to develop, and Sanders’ poise could make him a great fit.
2. Minnesota Vikings – With Kirk Cousins’ future uncertain, Minnesota could see Sanders as a long-term replacement.
3. New York Giants – If Daniel Jones struggles again in 2024, the Giants could look to Sanders as a fresh start at QB.
4. Denver Broncos – With Sean Payton at the helm, Sanders could thrive in a structured system designed to maximize his strengths.

Final Verdict: Is Cowherd Right About Shedeur Sanders?

Colin Cowherd’s comparison of Sanders to Brock Purdy is not without merit. Both quarterbacks excel in processing defenses, accuracy, and poise under pressure. However, there are key differences in their playing style, supporting cast, and career trajectory.

Sanders possesses qualities that make him an intriguing NFL prospect, but whether he can replicate Purdy’s success will depend on his landing spot, coaching, and ability to adapt to the pro game. If he is drafted by a team with a strong offensive system and protection, Sanders has the potential to become a franchise quarterback.

Ultimately, while Cowherd’s take may seem bold, it highlights a crucial point—NFL scouts should not underestimate Sanders simply because he played behind a poor offensive line. He has the talent, intelligence, and work ethic to succeed at the next level, making him one of the most intriguing quarterbacks in the upcoming draft.