Craig Carton Criticizes Jets’ Justin Fields Signing: Was It an Upgrade Over Aaron Rodgers

The New York Jets made a massive change at quarterback this offseason, signing Justin Fields to a two-year, $40 million deal ($30 million guaranteed). With this move, the franchise officially moved on from Aaron Rodgers, whose much-anticipated tenure with the team was cut short after just four snaps in the 2023 season due to an Achilles injury.

However, not everyone believes this was an upgrade. Sports radio personality Craig Carton didn’t hold back, calling the decision a mistake and claiming Fields is “not an NFL quarterback.”

In this article, we will analyze:

• Was moving on from Aaron Rodgers the right call?
• Does Justin Fields have what it takes to lead the Jets?
• What does this mean for the Jets’ playoff chances in 2025?

1. Craig Carton’s Harsh Criticism of Justin Fields

During a recent episode of The Carton Show, Craig Carton made it clear he doesn’t believe Fields is an upgrade over Rodgers.

“The answer is unequivocally no. Justin Fields is not an NFL quarterback, he’s never going to be an NFL quarterback. For some reason, collectively we’ve misjudged what Aaron Rodgers did last year because the Jets as a team were so bad. Didn’t win as many games as the year before with a plethora of quarterbacks. Aaron Rodgers threw for essentially 3,900 yards, 29 touchdowns, and 11 interceptions.”

Carton seems to argue that:

• Fields has not proven himself as a capable NFL starter.
• Aaron Rodgers was still a productive quarterback in his last full season (2022 with Green Bay).
• The Jets’ poor 2023 season was not Rodgers’ fault, but rather due to issues with the roster and coaching.

Is he right? Let’s compare Rodgers’ 2022 season and Fields’ 2023 performance.

2. Fields vs. Rodgers: Who Is the Better Option for the Jets?

Let’s break down how Aaron Rodgers’ last full season (2022) compares to Justin Fields’ 2023 season with the Chicago Bears.

Aaron Rodgers (2022 Season – Green Bay Packers)

• Passing Yards: 3,695
• Touchdowns: 26
• Interceptions: 12
• Completion Rate: 64.6%
• Passer Rating: 91.1
• Rushing Yards: 94

Justin Fields (2023 Season – Chicago Bears)

• Passing Yards: 2,562
• Touchdowns: 16
• Interceptions: 9
• Completion Rate: 61.4%
• Passer Rating: 86.3
• Rushing Yards: 657 (3rd among QBs)

At first glance, Rodgers’ passing numbers are better across the board. However, it’s important to consider:

1. Rodgers played in a better system with more weapons. The Bears’ offense lacked talent, while the Packers still had a solid O-line and running game.
2. Fields is a completely different type of quarterback. He’s a dual-threat player who adds value in the running game, something Rodgers never did.

So, while Fields hasn’t shown he’s a top-tier passer yet, he brings athleticism that Rodgers doesn’t. But does that make him a better fit for the Jets?

3. Why Did the Jets Move on From Aaron Rodgers?

The Jets’ decision to part ways with Rodgers was not solely about talent. Other key factors included:

1. Rodgers’ Age and Health

Rodgers will be 41 years old in December 2025. While Tom Brady played into his mid-40s, not every QB can do that. After a torn Achilles in 2023, it’s unclear if Rodgers will ever return to his former MVP level.

2. Fields Is Younger and Cheaper

• Rodgers was set to earn $37.5 million in 2024, while Fields’ deal is structured more team-friendly.
• Fields is just 25 years old, giving the Jets a younger QB who can develop.

3. The Jets Need a More Dynamic Offense

New York has struggled with offensive production, finishing near the bottom of the league in yards and points per game the last two seasons. Adding Fields gives them a QB who can extend plays, escape pressure, and add an extra layer to their running game.

However, does that guarantee success?

4. Will Justin Fields Succeed in New York?

While Fields has elite athleticism, his struggles as a passer are a major concern.

Fields’ Strengths:

✅ Elite mobility – Can escape pressure and extend plays.
✅ Big arm – Has shown flashes of deep ball accuracy.
✅ Toughness – Can take hits and still make plays.

Fields’ Weaknesses:

❌ Slow decision-making – Holds the ball too long, leading to sacks.
❌ Inconsistent accuracy – Struggles with timing and placement.
❌ Turnover issues – Fumbles have been a big concern.

If the Jets can improve his pocket presence and passing mechanics, Fields has a higher ceiling than Rodgers at this stage of their careers.

But if he doesn’t develop quickly, Carton’s criticisms may prove to be correct.

5. Can the Jets Make the Playoffs in 2025?

AFC East Outlook

The Jets will have tough competition in their division:
🏈 Buffalo Bills – Still Super Bowl contenders with Josh Allen.
🏈 Miami Dolphins – Explosive offense with Tua Tagovailoa and Tyreek Hill.
🏈 New England Patriots – Rebuilding, but always competitive under Bill Belichick.

Key Factors for Success

For the Jets to return to the playoffs, Fields will need:
1️⃣ Improved Offensive Line Protection – The Jets ranked near the bottom in pass-blocking efficiency.
2️⃣ Chemistry with Garrett Wilson – Their star WR needs to be the go-to target.
3️⃣ A Strong Running Game – Breece Hall must help take pressure off Fields.
4️⃣ Better Decision-Making from Fields – Reducing turnovers is critical.

If Fields progresses as a passer, the Jets could be a playoff team. If not, they could be looking for another QB in 2026.

Final Verdict: Was the Fields Signing a Mistake?

Craig Carton’s harsh criticism of Justin Fields is not completely wrong—Fields has not yet proven he can be a franchise quarterback. However, dismissing him entirely ignores his upside as a playmaker.

Why Fields Might Work:

✅ Younger and more athletic than Rodgers
✅ Brings a running threat to the offense
✅ Hasn’t yet reached his full potential

Why It Might Fail:

❌ Fields has been inconsistent as a passer
❌ Rodgers was still playing at a high level in 2022
❌ Fields might not be a good fit for the Jets’ offense

Ultimately, this move will be judged by how Fields performs in 2025. If he can take the next step as a passer, the Jets might have found their future QB. But if he struggles, Carton’s prediction will look accurate, and the Jets will be back to square one.

What do you think? Did the Jets make the right call moving on from Aaron Rodgers for Justin Fields?